Talk:Task:Maemo Brainstorm: Difference between revisions

From Maemo Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
← Older editNewer edit →
imported>qgil
imported>qgil
mNo edit summary
imported>qgil
Line 1: Line 1:
== Vote for IdeaTorrent ==
== Feedback ==
 
By --[[User:qgil|qgil]] 23:47, 7 May 2009 (UTC)
[http://www.internettablettalk.com/forums/showthread.php?t=24926 Poll closed and discussion made] - including internal chat with some Maemo SW product managers.
* Why not using the right column for Brainstorm navigation letting content start right below the header? Like we are doing elsewhere.
 
* I don't see the point of Milestones.
My humble recommendation to the maemo.org team will be to implement http://www.ideatorrent.org/ - which is the spin-off of the Ubuntu Brainstorm. It would handle the feature requests with a low entry barrier for contributions. bugs.maemo.org would be left for pure bug reporting.
* Categories are important. I will provide a list.
 
* Titles in comments don't show up. Not needed at all.
It would be good to have it running with som inertia by the Maemo 5 launch so the new generation of Maemo users would find it ready to get involved. This could mean have it before as alpha/beta, following more or less the same path than the Fremantle release itself.
* After voting some kind of transition should appear since it takes a while to get the vote registered and you are not sure whether you clicked well or not.
 
* The whole Brainstorm seems to be slow? Saving a page takes a lot.
About the tough bone of the user integration, it should be either a not very complicated hack or something solved (later?) through the single sign-on. I see no problem starting with new users if needed. The Wikipedia project didn't wait for user integration to start creating subprojects and become world most famous collaborative environment...
* Grey background? What about aligning with Talk style and make text run on top of white? Just an opinion.
* Pictures should resize automatically.
* Pictures can be uploaded in ideas (good) but they won't show up (bad).
* Missing somewhere a place saying how many ideas and solutions submitted, how many open to votes and how many implemented. A block/banner in the right column?
* Personally I like better the voting box from ideatorrent.org. Mainly the green/red arrows instead of hands. They bring strong clarity and color. Those hands... they don't look so so nice. No, in the news either. Again, just an opinion.

Revision as of 23:47, 7 May 2009

Feedback

By --qgil 23:47, 7 May 2009 (UTC)

  • Why not using the right column for Brainstorm navigation letting content start right below the header? Like we are doing elsewhere.
  • I don't see the point of Milestones.
  • Categories are important. I will provide a list.
  • Titles in comments don't show up. Not needed at all.
  • After voting some kind of transition should appear since it takes a while to get the vote registered and you are not sure whether you clicked well or not.
  • The whole Brainstorm seems to be slow? Saving a page takes a lot.
  • Grey background? What about aligning with Talk style and make text run on top of white? Just an opinion.
  • Pictures should resize automatically.
  • Pictures can be uploaded in ideas (good) but they won't show up (bad).
  • Missing somewhere a place saying how many ideas and solutions submitted, how many open to votes and how many implemented. A block/banner in the right column?
  • Personally I like better the voting box from ideatorrent.org. Mainly the green/red arrows instead of hands. They bring strong clarity and color. Those hands... they don't look so so nice. No, in the news either. Again, just an opinion.
Retrieved from "http://wiki.maemo.wunderwungiel.pl/index.php?title=Talk:Task:Maemo_Brainstorm&oldid=53703"